Skip to content
Gincave

Reviews GBR

The Botanist Islay Dry Gin: 22 Foraged Botanicals, Reviewed

The Botanist is Islay's only gin, built on 22 hand-foraged island botanicals. How it tastes, what the foraging actually adds, and how to drink it.

By Gincave Editorial · 3 min read
The Botanist Islay Dry Gin: 22 Foraged Botanicals, Reviewed

Islay is famous for smoky whisky, so a delicate, herbaceous gin from the island is a surprise, which is exactly what makes The Botanist interesting. Made by the Bruichladdich distillery, it is built on nine classic gin botanicals plus twenty-two more that are hand-foraged on Islay itself. That story could easily be marketing, but the gin backs it up: this is a genuinely complex, layered spirit and one of the best contemporary gins on the shelf.

What it tastes like

Where a London Dry is a clean, focused statement, The Botanist is a chord. Juniper is there, firm and proper, but around it sits a whole meadow: menthol and mint, chamomile and lemon balm, gorse and heather, a soft floral sweetness and a green, herbal, almost tea-like depth. It is aromatic and slightly wild, with the botanicals arriving in waves rather than all at once.

At 46%, it has real presence. The higher strength carries all those delicate notes and stops them collapsing under ice, and the finish is long, warming and herbaceous. This is a gin to slow down with.

What the foraging actually adds

The twenty-two Islay botanicals are the whole point, and they are not a gimmick. They are what give the gin its distinctive herbal, floral, slightly untamed character, the sense that you are tasting a specific place rather than a recipe. Picked across the island’s bogs, hills and shoreline, they push the flavour away from citrus-and-juniper convention and toward something greener and more aromatic. Whether that justifies the premium price is a matter of taste, but the complexity is real and hard to find elsewhere.

How to drink it

This is a gin that rewards restraint, because drowning it wastes what you paid for.

  • With a light tonic: a clean, neutral tonic and a sprig of fresh mint or thyme, nothing citrus-heavy, lets the foraged botanicals come forward. A sprig of rosemary works beautifully.
  • In a Martini: stirred and very cold, it makes a remarkable, herbaceous Martini that shows off every layer. This may be its best use.
  • Not buried in a sweet or flavoured mixer: the whole appeal is nuance, and a loud mixer flattens it.

The verdict

The Botanist is a premium gin that earns its price through genuine complexity rather than packaging. It is herbaceous, aromatic and unmistakably a product of its island, and it rewards attention in a way everyday gins do not. It is not the bottle for a careless, citrus-heavy G&T, and it costs accordingly. But as a gin to savour, in a restrained G&T or a cold Martini, it is outstanding, and a benchmark for what contemporary gin can be.

✻

Adjacent reading